NFL Expert Grading


NFL Industry Expert Grading

The Daily Overlay team keeps track of top NFL expert predictions. We then test this information each week and share it with our visitors and top performing experts. Our goal is to see who is great, who is really good, and who is not so hot, so you will know who to trust. If you think your predictions could make it to the top of the list let us know in the comments below and we may add you to the grading.

Note: We weight A+ selections very high because the payout is much higher. Our grading consists of the selections each site has up. If the site is late getting picks available they may not be included. We grade each NFL player against overall scoring, rank of scoring, scoring value(score/salary). They then receive the best grade from those 3 scales (because our grading system is damn hard!)

A+ A B C D F
Great play for GPP Win High GPP money In the money GPP Possible GPP money Will need lots of help from others A total Fail with this pick

If you would like to be notified when new grading information is released enter your email.

Updated weekly. Last updated January 4, 2017

Cash InExpertPicksA+ABCDF2016 Score
Get PicksDailyFantasyNerd1343016191221363.60
Get PicksDailyFantasySportsRankings2375232292332693.57
Get PicksFantasyTeamAdvice1573126191920423.54
Get PicksDailyFantasyCafe2314827273131673.42
Get PicksDailyOverlay - Value Index1853422252032523.23
Get PicksRotowire1673218221725533.20
Get PicksRotoGrinders - Consensus43677565854461453.16
Get PicksFantasyWired2414524332735773.15
Get PicksGoingFor21432712181426463.06
Get PicksDailyOverlay - Offensive Tendencies40673395249511423.03
Get PicksIndustry Consensus83414384104921192922.96
Get PicksDailyRoto8011338798971192772.94
Get PicksFantasyAlarm53679668163731742.91
Get PicksFakePigskin1292116151216492.91
Get PicksProFootballFocus1512513142225522.82
Get PicksRotoGrinders - Lineup Builder1432115192119482.82
Get PicksDailyRoto - Mayo50582535649721932.82
Get PicksSportsBlog36055414039471382.78
Get PicksMoxyball30547274131521072.76
Get PicksFantasyPros43470394842681672.74
Get PicksDraftKings - Playbook26146182519521012.74
Get PicksESPN - Love/Hate44862365562761572.60
Get PicksScout Fantasy1511717221625542.50
Get PicksRotoballer143209161422622.40
FantasyCruncher (Discontinued due to poor performance)80100250.88


NFL Grading Key